According to most adherents of the latter day saint movement, the book of mormon is a. Its interesting that were now talking about this when years and years ago ed ashment proposed. Hutchinson antiuniversalist rhetoric in the book of mormon dan vogel a rhetorical approach to the book of mormon. On nephis steel bow by common consent, a mormon blog. The book of mormon never mentions quetzalcoatl or any of ethans details of quetzalcoatls indian traditionssuch as bare feet, pierced ears, fieryflying serpents, green plumage, and more. Thomas early nineteenthcentury america and the book of mormon susan curtis the. Murphy, who for now has escaped excommunication from the lds church. This claim, as well as all claims to historical authenticity of the book of mormon, are rejected by nonlatter day saint historians and scientists. Ashment, former coordinator for translation services, church of jesus christ of latterday saints, is a doctoral candidate in egyptology at the. The pinnacle event in the book of mormon is a visitation from christ, himself. Critics contend ed ashment refuted hugh nibley on joseph. Its interesting that were now talking about this when years and years ago ed ashment proposed the same thing. According to most adherents of the latter day saint movement, the book of mormon is a 19thcentury translation of a record of ancient inhabitants of the american continent, which was written in a script which the book refers to as reformed egyptian.
These pages are written by jeff lindsay, a book of mormon aficionado, who takes full responsibility for the statements and opinions offered on this page. Ham, a textual comparison of the isaiah passages in the book of mormon with the same passages in the st. As a latterday saint, the most significant book you can understand is the book of mormon. Mormon times article on ifand conditionals miscellaneous. Also, some stories about the early time of the mormon church. I was traveling in rather distant and exotic climes which i cant mention, because it drives several of my critics absolutely insane with rage when they hear that ive been traveling, and had only poor and rare email access, so i failed to advertise the following prior to now. Howard a reinterpretation of inspiration, revelation, and scripture geoffrey f. Dissident lds intellectuals say excommunications will continue.
Threeedward ashment, melodie moench charles and stan larsonformerly worked in the churchs translation services. Deseret book, 1990a book that abounds with other fascinating evidences. For instance, although very little is known about the process of translating the book of mormon, for one who believes that joseph smith received any part of the book through the gift and power of god, it is a relatively small step from there to believe that the sermon at the temple was similarly translated and dictated under the direction of. A reappraisal, and other works scrutinizing the supposedly ancient provenance of mormon scripture. The book of abraham is a work produced between 1835 and 1842 by joseph smith based. Who really wrote the book of mormon the critics and. There are several theories as to the origin of the book of mormon. Marks isaiah scroll of the dead sea community ma thesis, brigham young university, 1961. Joseph smiths identification of abraham the dialogue journal.
The use of egyptian magical papyri to authenticate the book of abraham part 1. Aside from immaterial assertions about the constitution of the godhead, pre and postmortal existence, additional scripture including an historical book of mormon and book of abraham, mormonism stands valiantly as a christian church dedicated to those institutions, morals, and virtues that are the bulwark of our civilization. The use of egyptian magical papyri to authenticate the. Aside from immaterial assertions about the constitution of the godhead, pre and postmortal existence, additional scripture including an historical book of mormon and book of abraham, mormonism stands valiantly as a christian church dedicated to those institutions, morals, and. The book of mormon has been criticized for its lack of significant female characters in the narrative. The third volume i want to mention is jay todd, a longtime managing editor of the ensign had a fascination with this topic and he wrote a book called the saga of the book of abraham published by deseret book in 1969. If one or more works are by a distinct, homonymous authors, go ahead and split the author. Nov 10, 2016 ed goble posts quote while it is true that some of the ideological stances contained in ritners book are blatantly anti mormon, brian haugid for one is taking most of the information and the argumentation in ritners book very seriously. The impact of mormon critics on lds scholarship fairmormon. For those interested in the book of abraham issue, the book is well worth the price for ed ashments essay alone. Widtsoe, council of the twelve apostles, in search of truth. Printed for the griffith institute at the university press by v. Deseret book, 1987, 9, who accepts the statement of daniel ludlow, companion to your study of the book of mormon salt lake city. Joseph smith and the translation of the sermon at the temple.
With its approachable writing style and wealth of usable information, teachings and commentaries on the book of mormon is an invaluable resource for personal study, family instruction, speaking assignments, lesson preparation, missionary work, and more. This topic is discussed more fully in john sorensons article, fortifications in the book of mormon account compared with mesoamerican fortifications in warfare in the book of mormon, ed. Mormon challenges could the book of mormon story have. The most intensive examination of the logic of the various and often competing or contradictory arguments against the book of mormon has been provided by hugh w. This volume will change the way you read and study the book of mormon. The one linguistic category we know was not used in the production of the book of mormon english text is twentyfirst century scientific terminology, since this version of english did not exist in the 1820s. Because its ancient authors intended it to be read by future generations, it is scripture that is more relevant today than when it was written. To latterday saints there can be no objection to the careful and critical study of the scriptures, ancient or modern, provided only that it be an honest studya search for truth. What are some great commentary books on the book of mormon. Mcconkie and millets four volume doctrinal commentary on the book of mormon is good, although it is as conservative a series as you might guess a work by a man sporting the names of both joseph fielding smith and bruce r. Latter day saint scriptures and the doctrine of propositional revelation richard p. That is the angle the critics are trying for on this ed ashment vs. The prophet joseph smith called the book of mormon the most correct of any book on earth, and the keystone of our religion.
It was first published in march 1830 by joseph smith as the book of mormon. Books on the book of mormon 19892011 by an authorized editor of byu scholarsarchive. Joseph smith and the translation of the sermon at the. The brother of jared is the perfect example in the book of mormon where god doesnt always give the answers immediately there. Even a person who rejects the historicity of the book of mormon must agree that linguistic levels one and two are found in the book of mormon. Critics of the book of mormon have claimed that a variety of linguistic anachronisms exist in it which cast doubt upon its historical authenticity. Roberts, studies of the book of mormon salt lake city. Despite sorensons assertion of the existence of a number of ancient palestinian hebrew documents written in egyptian characters, defenders of the book of mormons claims have been unable to produce an authentic parallel. Lesko upon his retirement from the wilbour chair of egyptology at brown university june 2005 edited by stephen e. It created a firestorm of rejection amongst our lds scholars, but now here we are talking about this and agreeing with ed ashment.
Ashment, joseph smiths identification of abraham in papyrus js 1, the breathing permit of hor, dialogue. It is almost impossible to read more than a page without encountering mormon. The most common belief of adherents is that promoted by joseph smith, who said he translated ancient golden plates inscribed by prophets. Teachings and commentaries on the book of mormon deseret. Novak faithful history is a collection of essays from signature books that includes at least some of the recent discussion of the relationship of faith and history. New approaches to the book of mormon brent lee metcalfe, editor. Most adherents to the latter day saint movement view the book as a work of inspired scripture. The book of mormon a comparison with the 1830 ed and the. In the old testament, male pronouns he and his are mentioned 6. Edward ashment notes, the sign that smith identified with abraham. Allen illuminate the meaning of these scriptures and show how to apply doctrinal truths in our daily lives. Towards a critical edition of the book of mormon byu studies. Sperrys unpublished study, the text of isaiah in the book of mormon, ma thesis, university of chicago, divinity school, 1926. New approaches to the book of mormon explorations in critical methodology edited by brent lee metcalfe.
His is the voice that narrates the story of the book of mormon. Full text of book of breathings article by lanny bell. Teachings and commentaries on the book of mormon deseret book. Mormon was one of the two abridgers of the numerous records that went into making up the book of mormon, the other being his son, moroni. Dissident lds intellectuals say excommunications will. New approaches to the book of mormon signature books. However, on 14 february 1835, oliver cowdery, one of the three witnesses to the book of mormon, helped choose the twelve apostles. The book of mormon begins about 600 bc with a small group who fled jerusalem, landed in america, and quickly split into two antagonistic nations, the nephites and the lamanites. Bruce lindgren scholarship and the book of mormon mark d.
The book of abraham as a case study, in the word of god. And out of all these this is probably my favorite and so i recommend it, however you should be aware of two problems. Nancy ashment s husband ed is an egyptologist and the author of the book of abraham facsimiles. Martin harris as quoted by edward stevenson in the deseret news in 1881 described the translation. Evidence of ancient egyptian and hebrew in the book of mormon, in b. The book of mormon relates the religious history of the nephite nation for a thousand years until widespread apostasy about 400 ad. Nancy ashments husband ed is an egyptologist and the author of the book of abraham facsimiles.
Ed ashments article on the restoration of the facsimiles for publication in sunstone is probably. Commentaries and insights on the book of mormon alma 30. Deseret book and farms, 1988, 315, the prophetic book of mormon salt lake city. For those interested in the book of abraham issue, the book is well worth the price for ed ashment s essay alone. Ethan equates the whitebearded god, quetzalcoatl, with moses. Inasmuch as the sermon at the temple is appropriately nuanced and subtly different from the sermon on the mount, as the previous chapters show, one might well wonder how this occurred. Compare the similar view of kent jackson, nephi and isaiah 2 nephi 1125, in kent jackson, ed.
As a translator and this pamphlet was actually an attack on the book of mormon not specifically the book of abraham. Over the past few years the foundation for ancient research and mormon studies hereafter referred to as farms has published a critical edition of the book of mormon in three volumes. The use of egyptian magical papyri to authenticate the book of abraham part 2. New byu maxwell institute interview with brian hauglid. Who really wrote the book of mormon the critics and their. Ed goble posts quote while it is true that some of the ideological stances contained in ritners book are blatantly antimormon, brian haugid for one is taking most of the information and the argumentation in ritners book very seriously. Ed ashment had an article on the bom as a literal translation in sunstone that you. Ashment, former coordinator for translation services, church of jesus christ of latterday saints, is a doctoral candidate in egyptology at the university of chicago. It is a continuation of book of mormon evidences, part one. Commentaries and teachings on the book of mormon includes. They want us to believe that in this article ed ashment refutes hugh nibley, and by extension the mormon position on the joseph smith papyri, which in turns shows joseph smith is a false prophet. Critics of the book of mormon have long pointed to nephis bow of steel from verse 18 as a clear anachronism, as carbonized steel did not yet exist at that time. Full text of book of breathings article by lanny bell see other formats egypt and beyond essays presented to leonard h. The use of egyptian magical papyri to authenticate the book.
Bibliography a record in the language of my father. Evidence of ancient egyptian and hebrew in the book of mormon edward h. Smith claimed the angel moroni, a prophet in the book of mormon, directed him in the 1820s to a. Evidence of ancient egyptian and hebrew in the book of mormon, by ed. Book of mormon evidences, part 2 presents more of the factors that suggest the book of mormon may be an ancient document. An account written by the hand of mormon upon plates taken from the plates of nephi, who claimed that it had been. Smith is a summary of the multipleauthorship theory of isaiah and the problems it presents to mormon scripture. A fairmormon analysis of futuremissionary page the book of abraham. The book of mormon purports to be a history of the ancient inhabitants of the western hemisphere title page. Linguistic anachronisms in the book of mormon are words that represent concepts that are not believed to have existed in the americas between 2500 b.
1252 1395 1141 210 328 223 1018 869 358 21 1324 679 306 917 711 216 477 1151 225 247 279 973 145 1377 1508 624 471 707 1619 1056 237 43 1174 641 153 1497 1268 189 1171